WHAT WENT WRONG WHAT WENT WRONG

Practical Magic

Sep 14, 2026 · 1h 21m

Summary

Hosts Chris Winterbauer and Lizzie Bassett revisit the 1998 film *Practical Magic*, debating its structural flaws versus its enduring charm. They explore the adaptation’s journey from Alice Hoffman’s novel, highlighting Robin Swicord’s departure and Griffin Dunne’s controversial direction. The episode also details Dunne’s complex personal history, including his sister’s murder, and analyzes the casting of Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and introduction to the episode Initial reactions to Practical Magic and its pacing Memorable scenes and the origin of the novel Alice Hoffman's life and writing the book Robin Swicord's adaptation challenges Sponsor breaks for DripDrop and Quince Sandra Bullock's casting and career shift Dominic Dunn's life and the murder of Dominique Griffin Dunn's rise and the trial aftermath Griffin Dunn's vision and Nicole Kidman's casting Sponsor breaks for Citizens and ZocDoc Casting Aiden Quinn and the vampire confusion The witch curse incident on set Filming locations and production design details Tom Cruise's cameo and filming logistics The midnight margarita scene and music score Director's cut, editing, and critical reception The film's legacy and Griffin Dunn's perspective Praise for Sandra Bullock and the set design Cinematography, credits, and closing remarks
Listen ad-free on Castria