What to Carry, What to Burn What to Carry, What to Burn

Ep 15: George's Decision

Nov 10, 2026 · 43m

Summary

Host Blair Braverman recounts the 1914 Labrador expedition of writer Leonidas Hubbard and lawyer Dylan Wallace, guided by George Elson, a Cree-Scottish man. The ill-prepared group becomes lost and starves, leading to Hubbard's death and Wallace's survival. The episode explores the cultural dynamics and tragic outcomes of the journey, concluding with the moral dilemma Elson faces when both Hubbard’s widow and Wallace secretly request him to guide their separate attempts to repeat the expedition.

Topics discussed

Introduction to George and the expedition context Meeting Leon and Wallace in New York Departure and the initial journey north Struggles with bugs, heat, and slow progress Running out of food and growing despair Starvation, cultural differences, and Leon's journal Retracing steps and finding the maggot-ridden hide Abandoning the canoe and the decision to split up Leaving Leon behind and the final farewell George's solo trek for help and survival Rescue at the cabin and finding Wallace Leon's death and the revelation of the wrong river Aftermath, Mina's grief, and public criticism Wallace's request to redo the trip George's choice and the future expeditions

More from What to Carry, What to Burn

Ep 14: Redemption in the Yukon
Oct 27, 2026
Ep 13: The Lost Boy
Oct 13, 2026
Ep 12: The Raft
Sep 29, 2026
Ep 11: The Second Shipwreck
Sep 15, 2026
Ep 10: Jan Baalsrud
Sep 1, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria