We're All Insane We're All Insane

I Was The Other Woman…

Oct 18, 2026 · 1h 45m

Summary

A woman shares her journey from a small-town upbringing to becoming a real estate flipper, detailing how a failed business partnership with close friends led to her church community ostracizing her. This isolation and a lack of accountability contributed to a four-year affair with a married man she met through horse racing, which she describes as both the most exciting and destructive period of her life. She reflects on the emotional toll of being a secret, the realization that she had never truly known love in her first marriage, and the difficult path toward healing and self-ownership aft…

Topics discussed

Sponsorships and introduction Guest introduction and background Early life and the American Dream Marital struggles and separation Meeting Mav and building the barn Life planning and church conflict Sponsorship and early friendship dynamics Church response and failed counseling Renting the barn and new connections Buying horses and deepening bond Sponsorship and infertility struggles Realizing the marriage was over Crossing the line and divorce Sponsorship and post-divorce life Rock bottom and seeking new church The burden of secrecy Lack of resources for the 'other woman' Mary's suspicion and business ties Sponsorship and work dynamics Managing jealousy and distance Dating apps and new connections Confession and relationship boundaries Mav's excuses and the walk Public confrontation at church Ending the affair and seeking help Healing journey and foreclosure Meeting Rachel Long and new counseling Sponsorship and taking charge of healing Ongoing contact and Mav's suspension Selling the farm and final processing Moving on and maintaining distance Anniversary weekend and strong feelings Counseling advice and no contact The final goodbye text Four months later and new news Relapse in communication Mav's outreach and spiraling The group text confrontation Mary's silence and the truth Two years of silence Deciding to write the book Book release and ex-husband reaction Congratulating the ex-husband Grief and the burden of secrets Releasing the truth and family impact Book traction and community response Meeting people with humility and grace No reconciliation with Mav Soul ties and connections Falling in love with the wrong person Human connection and childhood wounds Thriving alone vs. craving connection Dating apps and high standards Courage to face public judgment Integrity as a core value How the affair started Grief as trauma and final thoughts Outro and sponsorships
Listen ad-free on Castria