Unexplained Halloween Special: Night Tales
Oct 31, 2026 · 31m
More History podcasts · More Science podcasts
Summary
Host Catherine Marsh investigates the 1975 murder of Rachel Calloway by her husband, Peter, who claimed he was possessed by a mysterious woman named Cassie. The episode reveals that Peter was formerly known as Daniel Greaves, a university student accused of raping a classmate named Cassie Linton in 1961, who later died by suicide. The story explores the chilling parallels between the two women and the unresolved questions surrounding the alleged supernatural events and Peter’s lack of recollection.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Base44, OnDeck, Sprite, and Rhapsido
Introduction and host's personal reaction to the story
The 1975 murder of Rachel Calloway in Ilsham
Discovery of Edith Smith's documents and her role
PC Edith Smith's arrival and the 'Cassie' statement
Discovery of the body and forensic details
Sponsor: Hearses for Curses
Background on Rachel and Peter Calloway
Peter's redundancy, depression, and withdrawal
Peter's involvement with the church group and Cassie
Witness descriptions of Cassie and Edith's investigation
Edith Smith's death and the missing clue in records
Uncovering Peter's past identity as Daniel Greaves
The 1961 rape allegation and the name Cassie Linton
Sponsor: Home Preservation League
Cassie Linton's life, trauma, and suicide
The alleged exorcism and Peter's account of the night
Edith's doubts and Peter's response to the host
Conclusion and final thoughts on the mystery
Credits and closing sponsors
More from Unexplained
Listen ad-free on Castria