Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps

Why the Olden Days Sucked

Nov 19, 2026 · 35m

Summary

Chelsea Follett discusses her book *The Grim Old Days*, which debunks the romanticized view of pre-industrial life by detailing the extreme poverty, disease, and violence of the past. She argues that modern economic growth and individual liberty have fundamentally improved human well-being, countering the nostalgic pessimism found across the political spectrum. The conversation also explores the causes of the Industrial Revolution and why material progress often fails to translate into perceived happiness.

Topics discussed

Introduction: The myth of the 'Good Old Days' Why Chelsea Follett wrote 'The Grim Old Days' The Great Enrichment and the hockey stick of GDP 1776: The birth of economics and the steam engine Public perception of the Industrial Revolution vs reality Political nostalgia on the right and left Sponsor break: Premium subscription details The 'Shire' illusion vs pre-industrial reality Childhood, marriage, and high child mortality rates Medicine: Bloodletting and the death of George Washington Dentistry: Tooth worms and public tooth-pulling shows Hygiene, alcohol consumption, and baseline health Malnutrition, famine, and historical cannibalism Adulterated bread and the power of narrative history Violence in the past: The 1595 law on beating wives Outro and call to action for premium subscribers

More from Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps

SPOILER SPECIAL: That Theranos Doc
Nov 17, 2026
Richard Dawkins on A.I. Consciousness
Nov 12, 2026
How does a feminist of the '70s view the activists of today?
Nov 9, 2026
But where are the young capitalists?
Nov 5, 2026
ELECTION 2026: What Everyone’s Missing
Nov 5, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria