True Crime Garage True Crime Garage

The Pastor’s Wife /// Mica Miller /// Part 2 /// 953

Sep 2, 2026 · 47m

Summary

The hosts discuss the Netflix documentary "The Death of a Pastor's Wife," examining the suspicious death of Micah Miller and the alleged abuse by her husband, Pastor John Paul Miller. They analyze conflicting evidence regarding her suicide, including a fisherman’s testimony and inconsistencies in the crime scene, while highlighting Miller’s controlling behavior and federal indictment for cyberstalking. The episode critiques how Miller manipulated the narrative post-mortem and urges listeners to watch the series for its detailed account of the case.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and introduction to the episode Theological perspective on abuse and divorce Micah's police reports and stalking allegations Police response and the danger of leaving an abuser Filing for separation and John Paul's reaction Micah's final hours and the 911 call Investigation details and suicide vs. foul play Extortion theories and stolen property Sponsors: Acorns, Chime, YouTube, and Quince Interview with the fisherman who found the body Critique of media reporting and mental health claims Micah's obituary and public image John Paul's manipulation and controlling behavior Pending lawsuits and FBI search warrant Legal updates and documentary review Sponsors: Angie's List and Morgan & Morgan
Listen ad-free on Castria