Today with David McCullagh Today with David McCullagh

We speak to Christa Pike's doctor – as she wakes and speaks after botched execution

Oct 8, 2026 · 12m

Summary

This episode examines the aftermath of Krista Pike's failed execution in Tennessee, where a judge ordered the preservation of evidence after she survived two lethal injections. Dr. Joel Zivett, medical advisor to Pike's legal team, reports that she has improved significantly, is off the ventilator, and is communicating, though she faces a long recovery due to severe arm injuries and a blood clot. Zivett attributes the execution's failure to IV complications and highlights the ethical concerns of keeping a recovering prisoner shackled in a hospital.

Topics discussed

Tennessee judge orders preservation of execution evidence Dr. Zivett details Krista Pike's improved condition Uncertainty regarding cause of initial unresponsiveness IV failure and blood clot as causes for botched execution Speculation on pentobarbital potency and state secrecy Prisoner rights and ethical concerns of shackling in hospital Estimating the timeline for physical recovery Ethical dilemma of treating a patient for future execution Separating the patient from the crime and medical duty Potential changes in execution methods and legal responsibility Critique of electric chair and the 'expert in unkilling' stance Risks and precedents of firing squad executions
Listen ad-free on Castria