Today with David McCullagh Today with David McCullagh

Smart watches: paranoid parenting or helpful for kids?

Oct 23, 2026 · 10m

Summary

This episode explores whether children's smartwatches are a useful safety tool or an unnecessary screen, featuring family digital coach Ruth Buckley and presenter Dominique McMullen. The guests discuss the varying capabilities of these devices, the social pressure parents face, and the potential for constant location tracking to increase anxiety rather than provide peace of mind. They advise delaying introduction until a genuine need arises, managing settings strictly to minimize distraction, and recognizing that individual children have different readiness levels for technology.

Topics discussed

Introduction and overview of smartwatch features Parental motivations: safety, connection, and social pressure Ruth Buckley's view on delaying tech and personal impact Dominique McMullen's stance and peer pressure from neighbors The anxiety trade-off of constant GPS tracking Balancing independence with the feeling of being tethered Best practices for managing smartwatch settings and usage Considerations for separated or divorced parents Individual child differences and tech-savvy kids Privacy concerns and the complexity of data settings Listener texts and the value of delaying devices
Listen ad-free on Castria