Today with David McCullagh Today with David McCullagh

Criminal Solicitors dispute full escalation from today

Oct 19, 2026 · 15m

Summary

Criminal defense solicitors have withdrawn all legal aid services, including for custody and child cases, after the Minister for Justice refused to negotiate a new payment scheme. Amanda Connolly of the Law Society argues the current model is unsustainable for complex cases, while Senator Anne Rabbit defends the Minister’s engagement and cites efficiency gains in the new system. The dispute remains unresolved as a judicial review is adjourned to November, raising concerns about the collapse of the criminal justice system for vulnerable defendants.

Topics discussed

Introduction: Escalation in criminal legal aid dispute Solicitors withdraw all services; Minister refuses to engage Timeline of failed negotiations and judicial review delay Senator Rabbit defends Minister's engagement and new scheme stats Amanda Connolly argues scheme harms vulnerable clients Debate on legal aid cert drop vs. system efficiency Call for mediator and criticism of full withdrawal Focus on vulnerable groups and system collapse Financial viability: Complex cases vs. simple hearings Review of complex cases and data gathering progress Final arguments: Multiple certs and specific asks
Listen ad-free on Castria