Today with David McCullagh Today with David McCullagh

Barry Cummins reports on the amazing and unusual case of Beth Ann Carpenter

Nov 3, 2026 · 11m

Summary

Crime reporter Barry Cummins discusses the case of Beth-Anne Carpenter, a US lawyer arrested in Dublin in 1997 for the 1994 murder of her brother-in-law. Despite maintaining her innocence and refusing a plea deal, she was convicted based on testimony from her ex-lover and the hired hitman, both of whom have since been released. Carpenter now faces life without parole, serving nearly 30 years in prison while the men who directly arranged and committed the crime have already served their sentences.

Topics discussed

Introduction to the case of Beth-Anne Carpenter Record-breaking prison sentence and current status Background: The murder of Buzz Clinton in 1994 The hitman and lawyer: Dupre and Klein's confessions Klein's motive: Affair and concern for sister Carpenter's denial and move to London How Carpenter helped police catch Klein Klein's accusation and Carpenter's undoing Life in Dublin and the arrest at the gym Extradition delays and death penalty concerns Legal challenges and misreporting by US authorities Supreme Court ruling and extradition to US Trial, jury verdict, and life without parole Contrast in sentences: Carpenter vs. Dupre and Klein Current legal efforts and conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria