511 - The 1991 Austin Yogurt Shop Murders
Summary
This episode of Timesuck with Dan Cummins examines the 1991 Austin Yogurt Shop Murders, where four teenage girls were killed in a brutal, unsolved crime. The host contrasts this tragedy with the 1966 UT Tower shooting, highlighting how the yogurt shop case shattered Austin’s sense of safety due to the unknown perpetrator. The narrative details the victims’ final hours, the horrific discovery of their bodies, and the subsequent flawed police investigation plagued by internal strife and limited forensic technology.
Topics discussed
Intro, Mint Mobile ad, and 1991 Texas crime context
Episode setup: The Yogurt Shop Murders overview
Profiles of the four victims and their day
The night of the murders: Customers and staff
Discovery of the bodies and initial police response
Robert Brashers: The true killer's history
The wrongful suspects: The four boys investigated
Investigation flaws: Satanism panic and bad leads
Police burnout, PTSD, and case mismanagement
Coerced confessions from Mike Scott and Rob Springsteen
Trial, exoneration, and DNA evidence linking Brashers
Recap, LDS genealogy vault, and cold case resolution
Outro, listener mail, and sponsor ads
Listen ad-free on Castria