The FBI's Least Wanted : Kimberly Kessler
Aug 17, 2026 · 43m
Summary
This episode details the 2018 disappearance of Jolene Cummings in Florida, which led to the arrest of her coworker Jennifer Seibert. Investigators uncovered that Seibert was actually Kimberly Kessler, a fugitive living under a stolen identity who murdered Jolene after fearing exposure. Kessler attempted an insanity defense by acting erratically in jail and court, but was found competent and guilty. She was sentenced to life in prison without parole, though she never revealed the location of Jolene’s remains.
Topics discussed
Jolene Cummings goes missing on Mother's Day
Investigation focuses on ex-husband Jason Cummings
Suspect Jason G and coworker Jennifer come under scrutiny
Surveillance footage and arrest of Jennifer Seibert
Jennifer's true identity as fugitive Kimberly Kessler
Kessler's history of lying and manipulating her mother
Kessler feigns insanity to avoid trial
Conviction, sentencing, and final thoughts on the case
Listen ad-free on Castria