Episode 296 – Yesteryear
Summary
Hosts Kate and Renata are joined by author S.J. Jones to discuss Cara Claire Burke’s viral novel *Yesteryear*. They critique the book’s portrayal of a “trad wife” influencer transported to 1855, debating its satirical merit and character consistency. The group analyzes Natalie’s unreliable narration, her problematic religious background, and the plot’s three timelines, ultimately questioning whether the story delivers on its darkly comedic premise.
Topics discussed
Introduction and book overview
Hosts' initial impressions and reading experience
Critique of satire and suspension of disbelief
Plot summary: Natalie's trad wife life and family
Analysis of Natalie's religious beliefs and hypocrisy
The 1855 timeline and Natalie's college backstory
College life, roommate Rena, and character inconsistencies
Critique of religious portrayal and marriage proposal
Early motherhood struggles and buying the farm
Caleb's manosphere descent and farming failures
Social media rise and the illusion of perfection
The 1855 mystery and Shannon's confrontation
The twist: Psychotic break vs. time travel
Final verdict on the book's themes and execution
Dramatic readings from the book
Similar book recommendations and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria