The Worst Bestsellers The Worst Bestsellers

Episode 297 – Verity

Sep 14, 2026 · 1h 21m

Summary

Renata, Kate, and guest Jake discuss Colleen Hoover’s *Verity*, a thriller about a struggling writer hired to finish a comatose author’s series. They critique the book’s implausible plot points, such as the protagonist’s delayed reading of a dark manuscript and the protagonist’s immediate acceptance of a violent solution. The hosts also joke about the author’s lack of research regarding New York and the Midwest, while noting the book’s recent film adaptation.

Topics discussed

Introduction and guest welcome Backstory: How the guest got the book Live podcast announcement and content warnings Steak 'n Shake and podcast sponsor lore Plot setup and research nitpicks Lowen's financial struggles and social media aversion The job offer and the term 'chronics' Arrival in Vermont and meeting the family The headboard teeth marks and sexual tension Discovering the manuscript 'So Be It' Manuscript details: pregnancy and twins The twins' deaths and naming Chastin Spooky occurrences and sleepwalking Jeremy's behavior and the manuscript's darkness The birthday cake and Verity's appearance The canoe accident and the manuscript's end Confronting Jeremy and the murder method The epilogue and the letter's purpose Comparing the epilogue to the original ending Movie adaptations and genre reflections Dramatic readings from the book Book recommendations for thriller fans Alternative ending brainstorming Duarte's Corner: Guest opinions Outro and next episode preview
Listen ad-free on Castria