The Totally Football Show with James Richardson The Totally Football Show with James Richardson

Totally Extra: Andy Cole - the Premier League's most underrated goalscorer?

Sep 5, 2026 · 1h 6m

Summary

This episode features a special "Total Extra" focusing on Andy Cole, with guests Tom Williams, Daniel Story, and Andy Mitten. The hosts discuss Cole’s journey from his record-breaking move to Newcastle to his time at Manchester United, exploring his complex relationships with teammates like Teddy Sheringham and his transformative partnership with Dwight Yorke. They analyze why Cole is often overlooked in Premier League history despite his prolific scoring record and highlight his crucial role in United’s 1999 treble, including the famous comeback against Juventus.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: ZachDoc Sponsor: The Girls Podcast Sponsor: Whole Foods Market Intro: Andy Cole tribute and trip recap Tom's 7-day trip with Andy Cole in Ireland The Belfast rave incident and Cole's background Cole's legacy and Premier League scoring records Early career: Newcastle and the Beardsley partnership The Cole and Dwight York partnership Almanac: Football history from September The move to Newcastle and the laundry story Newcastle's rise and Cole's record-breaking season The record transfer to Manchester United Early struggles and the 1995 title disappointment Media criticism and personal resilience The feud with Teddy Sheringham Sponsors: ZachDoc, Girls Podcast, JBL Dwight York's arrival and the 1999 Treble The 3-3 draw with Barcelona and iconic goals The 1999 Champions League Final vs Juventus Sponsors: ZachDoc, Whole Foods, Apple Cash Later career: Blackburn and Manchester City International career and the Hoddle criticism Tom's trip details and Cole's personality Quiz: Top Premier League goal-scoring partnerships Outro and Ronaldo anecdote Sponsor: JBL Headphones Sponsor: BenQ Golf Projectors

More from The Totally Football Show with James Richardson

Is Pochettino prepared for Man United’s trip to Anfield?
Nov 19, 2026
Totally Extra: Italy's hat-trick of World Cup fails
Nov 17, 2026
Spain 2-3 England LIVE reaction
Nov 16, 2026
Kane qualifies England for quarter-finals as Italy stun France
Nov 13, 2026
Pochettino set to become Man United manager
Nov 11, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria