The Sheridan Tapes The Sheridan Tapes

Omnibus 03: "The Second Death of Agate Shore"

Jul 18, 2026 · 1h 19m

Summary

Detective Sam Bailey returns to his hometown of Agate Shore, a dying community destroyed by a dam that drained its lake. He reunites with colleague Alan Gott, navigating their budding romance while investigating a series of mysterious drownings linked to a supernatural entity in the lake bed. The episode explores themes of grief, memory, and the haunting legacy of a place that demands sacrifice, culminating in Sam confronting the dark bargain he made as a child.

Topics discussed

Sam Bailey meets Alan Gott at the station Alan offers Sam a warm office Reflections on the memory of abandoned places Sam recalls his parents and childhood The town's reliance on the lake and tourists The dam project and the town's fate New Year's party and Sam's fall Sam's near-drowning and the voice Alan tends to Sam's head injury The town's slow decline after the lake dried Alan and Sam's breakfast and feelings Alan's story of falling in love with Sam The town's stagnation and a child's drowning Police reports and the discovery of a body Sam's sleep issues and the strange water smell The rain, the lake's return, and a vision Glass Cannon podcast advertisement More deaths and the town's abandonment The paranormal history of Agate Shore Sam's childhood drowning and the voice The mystery of Sam's rescue Reflections on love, loss, and memory Sonic and the Intrepid Chaotix advertisement The voice in the water and places of power Realms of Peril and Glory advertisement NeferTV podcast introduction
Listen ad-free on Castria