The Rubin Report The Rubin Report

Psychiatrist Spots a Major Problem w/ Lindsay Clancy's Defense | Hannah Spier

Sep 5, 2026 · 25m

Summary

Dave Rubin interviews psychiatrist Hannah Spear about the Lindsay Clancy case and the controversial public reaction supporting the mother who killed her three children. Spear argues that feminist ideologies have distorted psychiatric diagnoses, leading to the pathologization of motherhood and a culture of victimhood. She contends that the defense’s claim of postpartum psychosis is medically inconsistent with Clancy’s behavior and that society must acknowledge women’s capacity for evil.

Topics discussed

Sponsorship and introduction of the topic Host intro and guest background Recap of the Lindsay Clancy case facts Clarifying diagnoses and media reactions Defining psychosis vs. premeditation Sponsorship and forensic evidence analysis Critique of feminist influence in psychiatry Social media trends and pathologization Psychopathic traits and filicide statistics Motivations behind public defense of Clancy The crisis of purpose for young women Impact on male-female relations and trust Dating advice and screening for red flags Role of social media in amplifying grievance Predicted legal outcome and jury dynamics Ideal societal resolution and consequences Closing remarks and guest promotion Sponsorship and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria