The Rewatchables The Rewatchables

‘Obsession’ With Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Joanna Robinson

Jul 28, 2026 · 1h 56m

Summary

Hosts Bill Simmons, Chris Ryan, and Joanna Robinson analyze the indie horror hit *The Substance*, discussing its cultural impact, rewatchability, and nuanced performances. They debate the film’s subversion of "nice guy" tropes, identifying the male lead as the true villain despite initial ambiguity. The episode also covers Indya Navarrete’s breakout role and her strong Oscar prospects, while comparing the movie to other decades of "obsession" cinema.

Topics discussed

Intro and Tremphaya ad Adobe Firefly ad Obsession movie intro and rewatchability Comparing Obsession to Fatal Attraction and Get Out Horror movie trends and social horror Bear's character and the wish plot Bear's pathetic behavior and entitlement Nikki's performance and Oscar chances Anne Hathaway category fraud discussion Comparison to Don't Worry Darling and 500 Days of Summer Social media generation and isolation themes Box office success and horror genre revival Director Cory Barker and indie film success Key scenes: The dead cat sandwich and boys night Rewatchables format and production details Timeline, location, and minor details The Wish Willow and grammar loopholes Fake awards and character analysis The smell of the house and body odor Casting choices and Andy Richter Production secrets and audition stories Plot holes and police oversight Alternative endings and wish scenarios Final thoughts and sign off
Listen ad-free on Castria