Why Do We Turn on Innocent People?
Oct 4, 2026 · 51m
More Science podcasts
Summary
Hosts Michael Stevens and Hannah Fry explore the psychology of false accusations and witch hunts, using the Richard Jewell case and the McMartin preschool panic as primary examples. They analyze how confirmation bias, belief perseverance, and social media outrage amplify misinformation and mob mentality. The episode also covers historical parallels like the Gestapo and Salem trials, illustrating how personal gain and fear drive unjust accusations.
Topics discussed
Introduction: Lying and false accusations
Sponsors: Cancer Research UK and Checkout.com
The Richard Jewell case and the Olympic bombing
The victim's notoriety and the initial tip-off
Historical context: Gestapo and personal vendettas
Psychology of accusation: Diffusing guilt and fear
The McMartin Preschool and Satanic Panic era
Why the 90s were ripe for mass hysteria
Cognitive biases: Confirmation bias and guilty behavior
Belief perseverance and the lack of evidence
Sponsors: Rest is Entertainment and Apple Watch
Michael's false accusations and Minefield methodology
Conformity: The Asch experiment and social pressure
Social media outrage and the spread of misinformation
Outrage fatigue and the limits of digital communication
Personal anecdotes and the Dingo ate the baby case
Aftermath: Richard Jewell's life and legal battles
Balancing presumption of innocence with safety
The game Mafia and identity in accusations
Closing remarks and final sponsors
More from The Rest Is Science
Listen ad-free on Castria