203. Watergate: The Spies Who Went Rogue (Ep 2)
Nov 9, 2026 · 56m
More History podcasts
Summary
This episode details the CIA’s complicity in the Plumbers’ illegal operations, including the failed break-in at Daniel Ellsberg’s psychiatrist’s office and the provision of surveillance equipment to Howard Hunt. The narrative follows G. Gordon Liddy’s transition to CREEP, where he pitches the controversial "Gemstone" plan to Attorney General John Mitchell for political sabotage. Despite ambiguous approval, Liddy recruits Cuban operatives and secures funding to target the Democratic National Committee, setting the stage for the Watergate break-in.
Topics discussed
Introduction: CIA officer and the LA psychiatrist break-in
Recap: Nixon's paranoia and the creation of The Plumbers
Sponsor segments: HP, Wise, and Solana Breakpoint
The plan to break into Dr. Fielding's office to smear Ellsberg
Hunt uses CIA Technical Services for gadgets and disguises
The break-in: Casing the office and using a cleaner
CIA internal concerns and the Cushman memo restricting support
Hunt's continued requests and the search for a break-in team
Recruiting Cuban operatives: Bernard Barker (Macho)
Ambiguity of CIA involvement and the Martinez connection
Miami station confusion and Langley's response to Hunt's claims
Conspiracy theories: CIA behind Watergate or just complicit?
The failed break-in and the LAPD investigation
Obtaining the psychiatric profile of Daniel Ellsberg
The formation of CREEP and the shift to political intelligence
Liddy's wild schemes and the use of CIA graphics
The Gemstone Plan pitch: Kidnapping and Nazi tactics
The full list of Gemstone operations and AG's reaction
Budget cuts: Burning the charts and scaling down the plan
Ambiguous approval: Haldeman, Mitchell, and the lack of a 'no'
Sponsor segments: Petivity, Trimphia, and Carvana
Recruiting the team: Cross-country trips and Liddy's dinner
Hunt's Miami recruitment and the 'Ruby 2' asset
Prioritizing the Watergate break-in and cost estimates
E. Howard Hunt's background and the E. Howard Hunt incident
McCord's role and sourcing equipment from a CIA contractor
J. Edgar Hoover's death and the anti-war counter-demonstration
The failed break-in at the McGovern campaign headquarters
Targeting the DNC at the Watergate Hotel
Outro and Declassified Club promotion
Sponsor segment: Espolon Tequila
More from The Rest Is Classified
Listen ad-free on Castria