The Press Box The Press Box

John Madden Deserved Better Than ‘Madden.’ Plus, the Latest on Joe and Troy!

Nov 19, 2026 · 1h 12m

Summary

Hosts Brian Phillips and David Shoemaker critique the new John Madden biopic, arguing it lacks narrative focus and mischaracterizes the legend through Nick Cage’s performance, while praising Christian Bale’s portrayal of Al Davis. The duo also discusses the New York Times’ failure to aggregate real-time social media discourse regarding the NVIDIA scandal and shares their go-to books for overcoming writer’s block.

Topics discussed

Critique of New York Times coverage and social media discourse Discussion on AI, Jensen Huang, and media narrative gaps Film criticism and the use of expert sources in journalism Buzz Bissinger's leather jacket story and celebrity fixation Survey: Writers and books that help when you forget how to write Introduction to the movie 'Madden' and John Madden's legacy Madden's career transition from coach to announcer Critique of the film's structure and portrayal of coaching failures John Madden's personal life, marriage, and posthumous complexity Analysis of Nick Cage's performance and missed opportunities Christian Bale as Al Davis and casting alternatives The video game subplot and the film's thematic incoherence Personal anecdotes about John Madden's travel and media deals J.D. Vance, Trump, and the political fallout of the Iran war Conspiracy theories on Vance's strategy for 2028 Troy Aikman's comments on The Ticket and ESPN tensions ESPN's handling of the Aikman-Buck conflict and Super Bowl media day Speculation on Aikman's contract and potential return to ESPN Final thoughts on media narratives and upcoming show preview

More from The Press Box

How Trump Lost the Podcast Bros. Plus, the RGIII-Desmond Howard Twitter Beef.
Nov 17, 2026
The Five Worst Candidates of 2026. Plus, Senator Kane?!
Nov 12, 2026
Ross Douthat Grills Trump. Plus: Russini’s Return.
Nov 9, 2026
How Democrats Blitzed the Midterms With JB Pritzker
Nov 7, 2026
The Democrats Win in a Texas-Sized Blowout
Nov 4, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria