The Political Scene | The New Yorker The Political Scene | The New Yorker

Malcolm Gladwell on “The American Way of Killing”

Sep 21, 2026 · 27m

Summary

Malcolm Gladwell discusses his new book, The American Way of Killing, arguing that the U.S. gun violence debate is dishonest and misfocused. He challenges the historical narrative of the Second Amendment, linking it to slave control, and explains that expressive violence, not instrumental crime, drives most deaths. Gladwell critiques ineffective assault rifle bans and advocates for increased police funding and community-based interventions, like those in Baltimore, to break cycles of retaliation.

Topics discussed

Introduction to Malcolm Gladwell and 'The American Way of Killing' Why homicide rates mislead and the dishonesty of gun debates The original intent of the Second Amendment and militias Instrumental vs. expressive violence in gun deaths Critique of assault rifle bans and the lethality of handguns Baltimore's community-led strategy to reduce homicide The futility of long-term legislative battles on guns Police staffing levels and the inverse relationship with brutality Reforming police: response times and de-escalation Why youth carry guns: fear and lack of trust in police Outro and sponsor promotions
Listen ad-free on Castria