The Perfect Scam The Perfect Scam

Archive Episode: A Reality TV Star's Telemarketing Scheme

Sep 4, 2026 · 45m

Summary

Host Bob Sullivan interviews Penny Puckett, who lost $30,000 and her family farm to a business coaching scam linked to Jen Shah of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. Shah pleaded guilty to fraud and money laundering, facing prison time and restitution. Former FTC attorney Cindy Lebes explains telemarketing laws and advises listeners to verify offers and report scams to authorities.

Topics discussed

Introduction: Penny Puckett's $30,000 loss Penny's hobby: Special car seat blankets Trying to save the family farm with online sales The scam: Aggressive upselling and high fees Realizing the website didn't work Financial ruin and selling the farm ABC News contacts Penny about Jen Shah Jen Shah's Real Housewives fame and fraud Shah's arrest, trial, and guilty plea Penny's reaction to Shah's apology and sentence Recovery: Getting partial refunds and moving on Expert insight: How telemarketing scams work Legal protections and red flags to watch for Advice: Reporting scams and protecting yourself
Listen ad-free on Castria