The Perfect Scam The Perfect Scam

Archive Episode: FBI and Grandmother Bring Down Crime Ring, Part 1

Jul 31, 2026 · 25m

Summary

Susan Donald falls victim to a grandparent scam, handing $9,000 to a courier after being tricked into believing her grandson was in jail. Unlike typical cases, her doorbell camera captures the suspect, providing crucial evidence. Retired FBI agent and Survivor alum Brady Fenton leads the investigation, using the video to target a broader criminal ring. The episode highlights the challenges of elder fraud and the unique path this case took toward justice.

Topics discussed

Introduction: The Grandparent Scam and FBI Investigation Susan Donald's Life in San Diego and Family Context The Fraudulent Phone Call: Fake Accident and Jail Threat Pressure to Pay: The Fake Attorney and Cash Withdrawal The Handoff: Messenger Arrives and Phone Goes Silent Realization of Scam and Reporting to Police Police Investigation and Video Evidence FBI Agent Brady Fenton Joins the Case Challenges in Elder Fraud and Federal Involvement Cliffhanger, Sponsor Messages, and Credits
Listen ad-free on Castria