Bad Neighbor: The Man Who Defrauded a Small Town, Part 1
Summary
In this episode, host Bob Sullivan details the collapse of Burt Marshall, a beloved Hamilton, New York, resident who ran a massive Ponzi scheme for decades. Marshall, who managed taxes and insurance for the community, lured nearly a thousand locals and organizations into investing $94 million in his high-yield accounts. The scheme unraveled in 2023 when he filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, leaving the town’s fire department, cemetery, and residents with frozen assets and profound betrayal.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Hamilton, NY and Burt Marshall
Burt's role in the community and local businesses
Rachel Owen's history with Burt and insurance
The tax office sign and the investment pitch
How the high-yield investment accounts worked
Burt's real estate empire and promissory notes
Personal relationships and birthday traditions
Managing finances after Tom's death
George Cowan's skepticism and the car tour
Social proof and institutional trust in Burt
The scale of the fraud: $94 million invested
Burt's arrogant personality and discouraging questions
The facade of success and regular statements
The first withdrawal attempts and delays
Chapter 11 filing and frozen assets
Community shock and media inquiries
Attorney General investigation and Ponzi scheme allegations
The collapse of the scheme and false security
Burt's continued presence and victim anger
Impact on the cemetery and closing credits
Listen ad-free on Castria