The Opinions The Opinions

The New Tactic Trump Thinks Will Rally Voters

Jul 25, 2026 · 40m

Summary

NYT Opinion columnist Michelle Cottle hosts David French and Jamel Bowie to analyze the escalating US-Iran conflict, criticizing the Trump administration’s lack of strategic clarity and MAGA hubris. The trio then examines Trump’s revived “red scare” tactics against Democrats, arguing that economic realities and voter dissatisfaction outweigh political fear-mongering in the upcoming midterms. The episode concludes with film recommendations, including Sidney Lumet’s *The Pawnbroker* and the Apple TV series *Cape Fear*.

Topics discussed

Intro: Hosts and early associations with communism Iran conflict: Escalation, posturing, and lack of strategy Clausewitz, political objectives, and military miscalculations War costs, gas prices, and MAGA hubris Midterm outlook: GOP loyalty vs. shrinking Republican base Red baiting: Trump's communist scare tactic vs. 1950s DSA extremism and internal Democratic factionalism Material conditions vs. discourse: Why red baiting fails The curling analogy: Fundamentals dictate election results Recommendations: The Pawnbroker and Cape Fear Recommendation: The Death of Stalin and closing thoughts
Listen ad-free on Castria