The Opinions The Opinions

Best Of: The Aesthetic That Explains American Identity Now

Aug 27, 2026 · 32m

Summary

NYT Opinion editor Maher Ahmad hosts sociologist Tressie McMillan Cottom and creative consultant Emily Keegan to discuss the mainstreaming of rural aesthetics in culture and politics. They analyze how trends like cowboy fashion, reality TV, and country music reflect a nostalgic political moment, particularly under Donald Trump. The conversation explores the link between perceived authenticity, manual labor, and voter anxiety, suggesting that future political success may depend on projecting a "handmade" image.

Topics discussed

Introduction and the rise of rural aesthetics Examples of country trends in TV, design, and comedy Political undertones and nostalgia for an imagined past How political narratives shape cultural storytelling Trump's urban roots vs. his rural political appeal The 'handmade' aesthetic and embodied leadership Country music renaissance and authenticity wars The cowboy figure as a symbol of safety and anxiety Taylor Sheridan's shows and the Trump-era soap opera Can Democrats harness these cultural trends? The need for authentic, 'handmade' political candidates Conclusion: Authenticity and the rural ideal
Listen ad-free on Castria