The Opinions The Opinions

How Roy Cohn Shaped Trump — and America

Sep 9, 2026 · 36m

Summary

In this episode of The Opinions, Carlos Lozada, Michelle Caudle, and historian Nicole Hemmer discuss the new biography *American Scoundrel*, which chronicles the life of political fixer Roy Cohn. The guests analyze how Cohn’s ruthless tactics and disdain for rules directly shaped Donald Trump’s approach to power, noting that Cohn served as a "proof of concept" for breaking norms. They also explore the enduring legacy of McCarthyism, arguing that while McCarthy died in disgrace, Cohn’s influence allowed that era’s paranoia to persist in American politics.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: The Fantastics on Broadway Introduction of hosts and guest historian Nicole Hemmer Introducing Roy Cohn and the book 'American Scoundrel' How Cohn's tactics shaped Trump's approach to power Distinguishing Cohn's influence from shared political archetypes Similarities in upbringing, privilege, and performative populism The philosophy of self-made rules and disdain for norms Overview of the biography's narrative and Cohn's character Cohn's transactional relationships with famous figures What is new in this biography compared to previous works Cohn as the 'fixer' for the American establishment Sponsor: New York Times Games The persistence of McCarthyism beyond Joe McCarthy Will Trumpism outlast Trump like McCarthyism outlasted McCarthy? The long-term damage to institutions and trust The role of courts and moral authority in holding power accountable Cowardice and complicity among elites and institutions Speculating on Trump's reaction to the biography Trump's nostalgia for the 1980s and his bond with Cohn

More from The Opinions

Trump Got Together With the Boys
Nov 21, 2026
Anthropic’s $2 Trillion Debut: Bubble, Breakthrough or Both?
Nov 20, 2026
‘There’s No Juice Left to Squeeze From MAGA’
Nov 14, 2026
New Leaders Emerge for 2028
Nov 7, 2026
What Democrats Can Do Now to Lower Costs
Nov 6, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria