The Opinions The Opinions

Tax the Rich? Easier Said Than Done.

Oct 30, 2026 · 8m

Summary

This episode examines California's proposed one-time 5% wealth tax on billionaires, intended to offset federal Medicaid cuts. The host argues the measure will backfire due to billionaire flight, valuation difficulties, and liquidity issues, noting that some researchers predict it will cost the state more than it raises. Instead, the discussion advocates for alternative strategies like strengthening estate taxes, increasing corporate rates, and closing borrowing loopholes to effectively address inequality.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: The Fantastics musical on Broadway Introduction: The push to tax the rich in California Host's stance: Support for fairness vs. concerns about backfire Context: Federal cuts and the proposal for a 5% billionaire tax Problem 1: Ease of dodging the tax via relocation Economic impact: Loss of income tax revenue from departing billionaires Legal challenges: Retroactivity provisions and ongoing threats to leave Problem 2: Valuation difficulties for private business stakes Problem 3: Low liquidity and the issue of borrowing against wealth Economic consequences: Discouraging growth and investment in California Federal wealth tax: Constitutional hurdles and Supreme Court risks Alternative solutions: Strengthening estate and corporate taxes Closing loopholes: Taxing borrowing against company stakes Political outlook: Wealth taxation in the 2028 election cycle Conclusion: The risk of focusing on ineffective policy approaches

More from The Opinions

Trump Got Together With the Boys
Nov 21, 2026
Anthropic’s $2 Trillion Debut: Bubble, Breakthrough or Both?
Nov 20, 2026
‘There’s No Juice Left to Squeeze From MAGA’
Nov 14, 2026
New Leaders Emerge for 2028
Nov 7, 2026
What Democrats Can Do Now to Lower Costs
Nov 6, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria