From In the Dark: The Journey
Sep 16, 2026 · 53m
Summary
New Yorker staff writer Ava Kaufman investigates a scandal involving a wealthy Los Angeles couple who used a self-created agency to recruit dozens of surrogates for children. The story follows surrogate Kayla Elliott, who becomes a whistleblower after discovering the couple had hidden multiple prior children and was under investigation for alleged abuse. As the FBI and child welfare agencies intervene, other pregnant surrogates face legal and ethical dilemmas about handing over their babies, exposing the unregulated and vulnerable nature of the surrogacy industry.
Topics discussed
Sponsorship and show introduction
Episode 1 teaser: The Journey
Kayla Elliott's decision to become a surrogate
Whistleblower allegations and industry implications
Kayla's life in Corpus Christi
Finding intended parents via Mark Surrogacy
The intended parents' profile and connection
Medical preparation and embryo transfer
The transfer procedure and family bracelet
Financial benefits and third trimester updates
Health complications and birth preparation
Birth of the baby and delayed arrival of parents
Post-birth interactions and emotional aftermath
Discovery of other surrogates and discrepancies
Surrogates form a group chat and suspect trafficking
Sponsorship and surrogates connecting
Evidence of mass breeding and FBI involvement
Investigation reveals 21 children and foster care
Unregulated industry and legal complexities
Stacy King's perspective and contract dilemmas
Navigating legal and social services confusion
Surrogates' ongoing communication with intended parents
Sylvia's defense and request for silence
Police investigation and alleged abuse evidence
Stacy's decision to keep the baby and episode close
Credits and New Yorker promotion
Listen ad-free on Castria