The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories

Episode 331 - Second Chance Slaughter - The Case of Brandon Howell

Aug 16, 2026 · 48m

Summary

This episode examines the Woodbridge Lane Massacre and its connection to the 1998 disappearance of Tabitha Brewer and Nicholas Travis. The host details how Brandon Howell, acquitted of the teens' murders, later killed five people in Kansas City in 2014. The story explores the legal system's failure to protect the public, as Howell was paroled before committing the massacre. It concludes with Howell’s life sentence and the enduring mystery surrounding Brewer and Travis.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and Blackstone's Ratio introduction The moral dilemma of letting guilty people go free Nicholas Travis and Tabitha Brewer's relationship The disappearance and discovery of the burned purse Brandon Howell identified as the last person to see them Talkiatry sponsor segment Father's investigation and discovery of Nicholas's body Nicholas identified; Tabitha remains missing Brandon Howell's subsequent violent crimes Reopening the case and the failed 2009 trial HERS weight loss sponsor segment Brandon Howell's parole and return to society The Woodbridge Lane massacre victims The manhunt and arrest of Brandon Howell Connecting Howell to the 1998 cold case Shopify sponsor segment Forensic evidence and guilty verdict in 2014 Reflections on justice and the unsolved Brewer case Sponsors and final thoughts on the case
Listen ad-free on Castria