Introducing | Examined: The Backfire Effect from Pushkin
Summary
Journalist Josie Duffy Rice previews her new podcast, "The Backfire Effect," which investigates the 1986 murder of Scott Macklam in Port Huron, Michigan. The episode details the chaotic scene where witnesses mistook the gunshot for a car backfiring and introduces retired detective Herb Wellser, who has spent decades uncovering police corruption and prosecutorial misconduct. Rice explores how the "backfire effect" and belief perseverance have allowed a suspect to remain in prison for 40 years despite alibi witnesses, highlighting the complex failures of the criminal legal system.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Agency Skin
Introduction to the Backfire Effect and the Macklam case
The morning of November 5, 1986: The 'backfire' sound
Setting the scene: Port Huron and SC4 Community College
Witnesses react to the gunshot and scream
Host Josie Duffy Rice introduces herself and the story
Initial confusion: Witnesses misinterpret the scene
Max discovers Scott Macklam and attempts to help
Scott Macklam is pronounced dead
Why this story captivated the host
Background on Scott Macklam: Life and personality
Scott's relationship with Crystal Merrill
Witnesses describe a car fleeing the scene
Descriptions of the suspect and inconsistencies
Sponsor: Murder True Crime Stories
Visiting Herb Wellser in Saint Clair, Michigan
Herb Wellser's career in the Port Huron Police Department
Herb's investigation into the Macklam case
Explaining the psychological 'Backfire Effect'
Scott Macklam's behavior and fears before his death
The police investigation begins and family reactions
Teaser for next episode and show credits
Listen ad-free on Castria