The Jordan Harbinger Show The Jordan Harbinger Show

1411: Banned Books | Skeptical Sunday

Nov 8, 2026 · 1h 16m

Summary

Jordan Harbinger and Nick Pell examine the "banned books" controversy, arguing that most US challenges involve school library removals rather than legal bans. They contrast this with true international bans and discuss landmark obscenity cases like *Naked Lunch* and *Boiled Angel*. The episode also analyzes Florida's "Don't Say Gay" laws, debating whether parental objections to specific content constitute valid censorship or overreach.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Progressive Insurance Show intro and episode starter packs Introduction: Are banned books really banned? Local library controversies vs. actual bans International examples: Communist Manifesto and Mein Kampf Context of reading banned texts in education Sunlight as disinfectant: Reading to combat ideas Personal anecdote: Buying top 50 Amazon books The Streisand Effect and 'Banned in Boston' New England puritanism and historical context Legal history: Obscenity laws and Naked Lunch The Mike Deanna case and obscenity trials Prosecution of non-consensual content producers Sponsor: Sequencing.com DNA testing Sponsor: Concierge MD telehealth services Sponsor: 6-Minute Networking course Consequences for Mike Deanna: Fines and restrictions Utah law on school book removals Defining obscenity for children and community standards Role of District Attorneys in book prosecutions The Miller Test for legal pornography Redeeming social value loophole in law First Amendment limits: Murder manuals Paladin Press and the cost of publishing Personal story: Writing a biography in Arkansas Supreme Court rulings on school libraries Florida's 'Don't Say Gay' law and book challenges State vs. local control over school libraries Fast-track rules for book challenges in 2023 Specific content in challenged books Florida restrictions on non-parent challengers Sponsor: FlyKit jet lag solution Sponsor: Cybersecurity Tapes and quantum threats AI takedown requests and religious objections Agenda-driven history in schools Attempts to remove historical documents Political environment and historical education Political tracts substituting for civics education Parents reading books at school board meetings Challenges to books with two dads Impact of challenges on library circulation Marketing strategy: Getting books banned Case study: 'Mouse' challenged in Tennessee Censorship of symbols: Swastikas and logos Out-of-print books and publisher avoidance Scholarship vs. anti-Semitism in historical texts Salman Rushdie and the threat to writers Harry Potter and the Satanic Verses on banned lists Media amplification of book challenges Social media outrage and echo chambers Potential for spiraling book challenges Historical precedents: Burning books and mandates Sponsor: Ernesta custom rugs US Information Service libraries and Fahrenheit 451 Removing books with racial slurs Legal limits on removing books from libraries Private events vs. public library power Private school removals and sales impact Appropriateness debates for different age groups Changes in publishing standards and illustrations Year zero mentality and cutting off the past Left and right censorship arguments Roald Dahl and Phil Collins legacy controversies Censorship of racial slurs in literature Streisand effect in campus book bans Protests as marketing tools Outro and disclaimer

More from The Jordan Harbinger Show

1417: She's Too Thin: Is It Your Place to Weigh In? | Feedback Friday
Nov 20, 2026
1416: Valerie Fridland | Arguing for the Good in Bad English
Nov 19, 2026
1415: Leanne ten Brinke | The Surprising Antidote to Poisonous People
Nov 17, 2026
Introducing Leap Forward
Nov 17, 2026
1414: Ex Cheated and Retreated, Now Custody’s Heated | Feedback Friday
Nov 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria