The Horror Virgin The Horror Virgin

440 - Obsession

Jul 20, 2026 · 2h 7m

Summary

Hosts Paige and Todd review the horror film *Obsession*, praising its practical effects and the terrifying performance of Shadow Nikki. They analyze the protagonist Bear’s parasocial obsession and poor communication, debating his villainy versus his naivety. The episode also covers the film’s tight pacing, low-budget success, and the director Curry Barker’s promising debut.

Topics discussed

Intro, patrons, and Lindsey Graham's death Shadow Nikki's terror and low-budget makeup effects Bear's selfishness and Ian's complicity Filming locations and personal trauma triggers Relatability of toxic relationships and sleep anxiety Host anecdotes on missing red flags in dating Bear's obsession vs. Nikki's agency and realism Acting nuances, voice changes, and alternate theories Ian and Nikki's secret hookup revealed The cat's death and Bear's neglectful reaction Ad read for Squarespace Ian confronts Bear and the trivia night setup The wish, the cat, and the 'Monkey's Paw' dynamic Nikki's manipulation and the 'Freaky' nickname Pet burial stories and Shadow Nikki's lies The restaurant meltdown and PTSD triggers Duct tape door and invalidating feelings Boys night exclusion and the Hansel and Gretel story Shadow Nikki's terrifying physical transformations Sarah's confession and the windshield scene Bear's suicide attempt and the wish's consequences The ambiguous ending and final verdict Fun facts: Long takes, makeup, and the wish pen Box office success and theatrical performance Next episode: Backrooms and listener reviews
Listen ad-free on Castria