The Horror Virgin The Horror Virgin

444 - Creep 2

Aug 17, 2026 · 1h 11m

Summary

Hosts Paige and Todd review the found-footage horror sequel *Creep 2*, with Paige admitting she enjoyed it far more than the original. They analyze the film’s comedic tone, comparing the protagonist’s dynamic with the killer to a twisted rom-com and discussing the actor’s performance. The episode also touches on industry topics like self-taping, imposter syndrome, and real-life Craigslist encounters.

Topics discussed

Intro, patrons, and community shoutouts Initial reactions to Creep 2 and watching with parents The struggle of self-taping for auditions Natalie's character flipping the script on the killer Critique of improv found footage and editing Recap of Creep 1 and the wolf mask motif Mark Duplass's performance and character depth Natalie as a foil: The lioness vs. the lamb Hypothetical ending: Natalie as a serial killer Scene study: The opening victim and low fear response Real-life parallels: Sleep paralysis and influencers Squarespace ad read Talkspace ad and real-life Craigslist encounters Imposter syndrome and Natalie's show premise The meeting: Boundaries, Iocane powder, and trust Power dynamics: Nudity and shifting comfort zones The woods, the hot tub, and the killer's breakdown The shower scare and the fake suicide attempt The locket, the chase, and the ambiguous ending Fun facts, box office, and scary scale rating Listener reviews, next week's movie, and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria