The Herd with Colin Cowherd The Herd with Colin Cowherd

3 & Out - Jerry Jones on paying premium for coaches, Giants should reconsider BIG TRADES, Miami-Notre Dame Preview

Nov 4, 2026 · 1h 5m

Summary

John Middlecoff analyzes Jerry Jones’s comments on coach compensation, arguing that while pay doesn't guarantee success, the Cowboys' failure to hire elite leaders like Mike McCarthy has cost them. The episode also covers John Harbaugh’s frustration with the Titans' silence regarding Jeffrey Simmons, Mark Davis’s decision to bench Fernando Mendoza, and the strategic choice for the Jets to retain Aaron Glenn despite his struggles. Middlecoff concludes by previewing the critical Notre Dame-Miami game and discussing the unique scheduling challenges facing the Fighting Irish.

Topics discussed

Sponsorships: State Farm and Ebclis Grainger commercial: The story of the one Preview: Jets and Notre Dame must-win games NFL owners avoiding press on coaching issues High-paid coaches vs. winning: Reid, McVay, Shanahan Jerry Jones and the Cowboys' hiring history Contract structures: Coaches and rookie QBs College coaching buyouts and NFL protections Respecting Jerry Jones' business mindset Why the Cowboys hire familiar faces over stars Dak Prescott's playoff performance analysis Coordinators to head coaches: Outliers vs. norm GM limitations once the season starts Jeffrey Simmons and the Bears' control dynamics Youth, money, and decision-making in football Mike Borgonzi's communication issues with agents Giants' QB situation and trade value analysis Are teams truly one player away? Context matters Giants front office structure and coach authority The importance of personal connections in business NFL networking: Poles and Morgonzi's history Jeffrey Simmons trade: Player agency and market Pete Carroll's bossy management style at Seattle Giants' impulsive trade risk with JJ McCarthy Sponsorship: Polymarket prediction market Sponsorship: Sniffy's Cruising Confessions podcast Host's past conflict with the Raiders organization Moving on from anger and professional criticism Mark Davis' hands-off approach to Raiders staff Raiders QB situation: Cousins bridging the gap Cal Poly struggles and learning by doing Anecdote: The genius roommate who never studied Raiders' new ownership influence and spending Raiders' realistic expectations and talent gap Fernando Mendoza's transition from elite college team Raiders' lack of equipment and philosophical beliefs Dysfunctional organizations and ownership interference QB development timelines: Nix, Mahomes, Brady Ravens' struggles and Lamar Jackson's injuries Advice for Jets: Fire Aaron Glenn after season Jets' draft assets and comparison to Titans Riding out negativity with Aaron Glenn Jets' draft picks and the Colts' selection Jets' draft capital and local radio rant Eagles radio style and personality-driven media Giants' record vs. talent and Dolphins example Tony Romo's perception and recent controversies Tony Romo's DQ and lack of preparation Speculation on Tony Romo's cognitive decline Notre Dame's unique business model in college sports SEC/Big Ten schedule difficulty and rotation Notre Dame's scheduling challenges and comparisons Notre Dame's losses to top teams and implications Brian Kelly era perception vs. current gap Miami's injuries and Belichick's performance Notre Dame's must-win game against Miami Consequences of losing to Miami for Notre Dame Marcus Freeman's failure to draw a line in the sand Complaint about Apple Watches in the darkroom Notre Dame's effort level and player quality Chiefs' offensive needs and Jets' trade stance Finding WRs in mid-rounds: Historical examples Chiefs' roster help and GM departure rumors Clay Kubiak's role and Shanahan's praise Colin's criticism of Steelers front office Steelers' offensive line and GM performance Omar Khan's role in hiring Mike McCarthy Caleb Williams' regression and growth timeline Personal anecdote: Dealing with a crying child Boise State RB draft pick analysis Raiders' draft mistake and defensive focus Evaluating small school players and highlight reels Al Michaels' cognitive decline and broadcast errors Al Michaels' specific errors and memory issues Sponsorship: Boost Mobile and Mike Tyson Sponsorship: Bank of America Safe Balance Sponsorship: Ebclis prescription medicine Outro: iHeart Podcast branding
Listen ad-free on Castria