The Hard Shoulder The Hard Shoulder

The fallout from the Ireland V Israel match

Sep 28, 2026 · 11m

Summary

The Hard Shoulder discusses the controversy surrounding Ireland’s Nations League match against Israel, with FAI President Paul Cook defending the association’s handling of the situation. Football journalist David Sneider critiques the FAI’s communication failures and the pressure placed on players, while former US Ambassador Dan Mulhall argues that the players should not face bullying for making a difficult decision under UEFA’s rules.

Topics discussed

Show introduction and guest introductions FAI President defends handling of Israel match Media criticism and the post-match press conference Journalist's surprise at FAI's lack of self-reflection Assessment of media coverage fairness and player autonomy The evolving situation and board decision-making process Lack of board presence and player reservations Shift in perspective on UEFA and government support Critique of 'Day of Infamy' headline and reporting tone Chaos at the stadium and unprecedented logistical issues Closing remarks to David Snide Dan Mulhall's background as a lifelong football fan View on the draw and FAI's independent decision FAI adjustments and international media coverage Criticism of bullying towards the players Validity of diverse player positions and final thoughts
Listen ad-free on Castria