The Hard Shoulder The Hard Shoulder

Does the brand of tea affect the taste?

Nov 2, 2026 · 10m

Summary

Hosts Ciara Kelly and Shane Coleman explore the Irish tea debate, debating whether one can distinguish between Lyons and Barry’s brands by taste. They are joined by journalist Aidan O’Connell and dairy farmer Finn Walsh to discuss their specific preferences, ranging from full-fat milk to loose-leaf brewing. The group then conducts a blind taste test to identify the two brands, revealing that while opinions vary on which is smoother, the hosts ultimately guess correctly.

Topics discussed

Intro and 'All Talk' ad read Introduction of guests and tea debate premise Aidan O'Connell on tea as a national drink Specifics of brewing: water, milk, and strength Personal brand loyalties: Barry's vs Lion's Finn Walsh's purist approach with tea leaves Milk preferences and family tea habits The blind taste test between hosts Revealing results and discussing flavor profiles Guest reactions and the ritual of tea drinking Other brands: Lipton, Bewley's, and travel tea Wrap-up and thanks to guests Shane reveals his guessing strategy and listener comments
Listen ad-free on Castria