The First 48 The First 48

The Break

Sep 3, 2026 · 38m

Summary

This episode of The First 48 follows Mobile, Alabama detectives investigating the murder of Tito Smith, who was shot during a bar fight. Investigators identify the suspect, Demetrius "Dirk" Anderson, through security footage showing him pulling a gun from a medical boot and witness testimony. After a multi-state manhunt, Anderson is arrested in Georgia, extradited, and convicted of murder, receiving a life sentence.

Topics discussed

Introduction: 911 call and case overview Crime scene investigation and surveillance footage Witness interviews and notifying the family Identifying suspect via medical boot and arrest records Failed stakeout and public appeal for tips Bar owner Rick Johnson's account of the shooting New lead: Victim's friend and suspect alias 'Dirk' Reconstructing the night before and locating eyewitness Interrogating the eyewitness and identifying Demetrius Confirming suspect identity and obtaining arrest warrant Arrest, extradition, and conviction of Demetrius Anderson Reflections from the bar owner and victim's family
Listen ad-free on Castria