The First 48 The First 48

Bad Cinderella

Oct 8, 2026 · 39m

Summary

This episode of The First 48 details the Tulsa homicide investigation into the murder of Dion Carr during a home invasion. Detectives race to identify the second suspect after one shooter, Chauncey Thomas, is dumped at a hospital and later dies from his injuries. By analyzing surveillance footage and cell phone records, police link the surviving suspect, Justin Harjo, to the crime scene and the suspect vehicle. Harjo is eventually extradited from Kansas and pleads guilty to conspiracy to use a firearm during a crime of violence, receiving an 18-year sentence.

Topics discussed

911 call reporting home invasion and shooting Show introduction and case overview Detectives arrive at the crime scene Gunshot victim dumped at Hillcrest Hospital Identifying suspect Chauncey Thomas Investigating the suspect's background and family Interview with the victim's girlfriend Hospital surveillance and vehicle identification Crimestoppers tip and search for the Kia Optima Tracking down the suspect's girlfriend Interrogating the girlfriend for leads Identifying second suspect Justin Harjo Episode summary and sponsor break Cell phone records place suspects at scene Surveillance and traffic stop of witness Witness reveals motive and events of the night Locating the burned suspect vehicle Arrest, charges, and guilty plea
Listen ad-free on Castria