The Fifth Column The Fifth Column

The Politics of Pretending (Episode #570)

Aug 12, 2026 · 1h 41m

Summary

Hosts Camille Foster, Michael Moynihan, and Matt Welch critique the political left’s retreat from "Woke 1.0" policies, analyzing AOC’s vague apologies and the Jason Arday academic scandal. They discuss the hypocrisy of Republicans who only oppose Trump after being personally slighted, mocking Tucker Carlson’s new political maneuvering. The episode also covers the seductive but dangerous appeal of socialism among youth, arguing that such ideologies must fail in practice to be discredited.

Topics discussed

Intro: Tequila, filibustering, and cargo shorts Senate hypocrisy and Trump's corruption Pronunciation fails: Gibraltar and Kerfuffle Race, gender fluidity, and Harper's Atlantic piece Critique of a poorly edited book on Oasis Race IQ studies and academic errors AOC's 'Woke 1.0' and defunding the police Cancel culture backfires: Kevin Hart and Gore Vidal AOC's vulnerability and Minneapolis riots Political opportunism and Trump's enemies Socialism's popularity and Chicago's grocery stores Zohran Mamdani and the Amazon Delivery Protection Act Bike tickets, rent strikes, and Mamdani's rent Roamer's interview with David Remnick on Putin Hassan Piker, Mao, and comparisons to Nick Fuentes Mao's legacy vs. American reform and slavery Midterm races: Ossoff, Vance, and polling Ben Sass, Sia Weaver, and DSA politics Ben Sass's career, illness, and Ross Douthat
Listen ad-free on Castria