742 - Alexander Hamilton - Part Three
Jul 14, 2026 · 1h 55m
Summary
Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds critique the musical Hamilton’s historical accuracy, exposing Alexander Hamilton’s elitist policies and secret pro-British dealings. They detail Hamilton’s scandalous affair with Maria Reynolds, including his payment of hush money to her husband. The episode highlights how Hamilton admitted the affair to deflect accusations of financial corruption, revealing his moral failings.
Topics discussed
Intro and banter about movies and gnomes
Ukrainian drones and war updates
Critique of the Hamilton musical's historical accuracy
Jefferson's alleged plot to establish a monarchy
Hamilton's Report on Manufactures and child labor
Hamilton's secret meetings and financial plans
The Reynolds Affair and Maria Reynolds
The publication of the Reynolds Pamphlet
Washington's retirement and the French Revolution
Sponsor reads for Mint, Nutrafol, and Squarespace
The Whiskey Rebellion and farmer protests
Washington's military response and the Jay Treaty
The Election of 1800 and Aaron Burr
James Callender's exposé and Hamilton's confession
Hamilton's duel threats with Monroe and conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria