How One Trick Play Tells The History Of Football
Summary
Host Josh Levine investigates the history of the "hideout play" after his grandfather, 97-year-old Erwin Miller, recalls seeing a Georgia Tech player score a touchdown while hiding on the sideline during a 1944 game. The episode traces this trick back to Amos Alonzo Stagg, a pioneering coach who viewed deception as central to the sport, and explores modern iterations, including a fake field goal by Georgia Tech kicker Scott Blair and a controversial play involving Johnny Manziel for the Cleveland Browns. Through interviews with players, coaches, and historians, the show examines the ethics …
Topics discussed
Introduction: Grandfather Erwin Miller and LSU
Life at LSU during WWII and the 1944 season
Y.A. Tittle and the 1944 Georgia Tech game
The Stretcher Trick: Papa's unforgettable memory
Replay Booth intro and episode preview
Scott Blair: Kicker turned trick play hero
The 2009 fake field goal against Clemson
Cleveland Browns and the Manziel hideout play
The fake argument and Manziel's touchdown
The penalty and the Browns' 2014 season
The rules: Why the hideout play is illegal
Modern examples and the 'perfect football crime'
Origins: Amos Alonzo Stagg and early football
Stagg's innovations and the invention of the hideout
Ethics, loopholes, and the Tush Push debate
Return to Papa: Discussing the research findings
History of the ban and George Matthews Jr.
Coach Bobby Dodd and the 1944 game context
Recreating the 1944 touchdown via radio accounts
Explaining the stretcher and final reflections
Outro, credits, and newsletter promotion
Listen ad-free on Castria