Ep. 1167, The Sign of the Four, Part 2 of 5, by Arthur Conan Doyle
Aug 21, 2026 · 58m
Summary
In this episode of The Classic Tales Podcast, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson accompany Miss Morstan to meet Thaddeus Sholto, who reveals the secret of the Agra treasure and his father’s death. The group travels to Pondicherry Lodge, where they discover Thaddeus’s twin brother, Bartholomew, murdered in his locked room with the treasure missing. Holmes begins his investigation, finding clues including a poisoned thorn, a wooden leg print, and tiny bare footprints in a hidden attic, setting the stage for solving the mystery of the Sign of the Four.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Gametime ticket app
Introduction to Classic Tales podcast
Sponsor: Classic Tales audiobooks
Description of Thaddeus Sholto and his home
Thaddeus Sholto explains his precautions
Sholto recounts his father's death
The mystery of the treasure and Morstan
Confession of hiding the treasure
The night of the intruder
Discovery of the treasure location
Journey to Pondicherry Lodge
Arrival and encounter with McMurdo
Entering the lodge grounds
Holmes recognized by the prize fighter
Waiting outside and Miss Morstan's fear
Thaddeus Sholto's panic over Bartholomew
Investigating the locked room
Discovery of the body and the sign
Holmes examines the crime scene
The missing treasure and Sholto's fear
Holmes analyzes the footprints
The mystery of the wooden leg
Deduction of the intruder's entry
Exploring the roof space
Discovery of child-sized footprints
The creosote trail and Toby the dog
Forensic analysis of the death
The poisoned thorn and stone instrument
Arrival of Inspector Lestrade
Lestrade's theory of murder
Holmes challenges Lestrade's logic
The card and the stone-headed instrument
Arrest of Thaddeus Sholto
Holmes promises to clear Sholto
Description of the criminal
Plan to find the criminal
Holmes sends Watson for Toby the dog
Outro and recommendation for Hound of Baskervilles
Sponsor: Happy GLP care
Sponsor: Organic Valley Protein Plus
Listen ad-free on Castria