The Celtic Underground The Celtic Underground

The many mysteries of Celtic’s first trophy

Nov 11, 2026 · 13m

Summary

This episode explores the mysteries surrounding Celtic’s first trophy, the Glasgow Northeastern Cup, won in 1889. It investigates conflicting historical accounts regarding whether Celtic actually received the original trophy that year, noting that it was likely repurposed for a reserve competition. The narrative also traces the fate of a grander replacement cup awarded in 1890, which has since vanished, possibly lost in Shawfield Stadium fires.

Topics discussed

Introduction: Celtic's first success in the Northeastern Cup The mysteries surrounding the 1889 trophy Celtic's maiden season and lack of silverware Origins and structure of the Northeastern Cup History of the tournament and Celtic's participation Celtic's 1889 victory over Cowlears Conflicting reports on the 1889 awards ceremony The decision to commission a new, grander trophy Debate over whether Celtic received the original cup Clyde's victory in the Second Eleven Tournament Evidence suggesting Celtic never held the trophy The original cup on display at Hampden Park Inscriptions revealing the trophy's repurposing Engraved names supporting the non-possession theory Celtic's 1890 victory and the new trophy presentation Praise for the new Northeastern Cup's appearance The mystery of the second cup's disappearance Possible scenarios for the missing trophy The theory of the trophy being repurposed The devastating fires at Shawfield Stadium Loss of items in the Clyde trophy room fires Decline of the competition due to league football Significance of the cup to Celtic's early history Summary of the enduring mysteries Conclusion and book promotion

More from The Celtic Underground

Andrew H in conversation with...Graham Spiers
Nov 19, 2026
Celtic and non-football stadia
Nov 18, 2026
Money, Money, Money…Now What?
Nov 16, 2026
A Packet of Revels
Nov 9, 2026
Celtic and footballing deaths
Nov 4, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria