The Breakdown The Breakdown

A Top Pollster Breaks Down the Numbers

Oct 14, 2026 · 30m

Summary

Host Dana Bash and polling expert Evan Rothsmith analyze the volatile 2024 election landscape, debating whether recent Democratic polling surges reflect genuine voter shifts or methodological errors. They discuss the "grievance versus governance" dynamic, highlighting why governor's races in states like Texas and Nevada are critical for Democrats to prove their administrative competence in 2028. The conversation also covers Donald Trump's declining approval ratings and his negative impact on down-ballot Republican candidates, concluding that while polling errors are possible, the current da…

Topics discussed

Intro and guest introduction: Evan Rothsmith Mike Johnson clip: Why polls are 'wrong' Polling accuracy in midterms vs. presidential cycles Methodology: Education weighting and rural voter bias Impact of potential polling errors on House control Modeling a fluid electorate: Sampling vs. modeling Senate races: Rural states and John Ossoff in Georgia Is Donald Trump helping or hurting Republican candidates? Republican triage and the Minnesota Senate race Why Governor's races matter for 2028 governance Surprising Democratic gains in Texas and other states Voter psychology: Senate vs. Governor ballot choices Trump's low approval and the 'hold your nose' wave Outro and resources for tracking polling
Listen ad-free on Castria