The Gossip Game: The Man Who Blackmailed the Gilded Age
Aug 14, 2026 · 59m
Summary
Host Carl Raymond and guest Joe Pompeo explore the scandalous history of *Town Topics*, a Gilded Age society magazine. They detail how publisher Colonel William Dalton Mann used the publication’s “Saunterer” column to blackmail New York’s elite with blind items. The episode covers Mann’s extortion schemes, including targeting Emily Post’s husband, and his eventual downfall.
Topics discussed
Whole Foods Market sponsorship
Introduction to Town Topics and guest Joe Pompeo
Guest background and historical true crime appeal
History of Town Topics and its publishers
Gilded Age media landscape and yellow journalism
Town Topics' unique position and target audience
Profile of publisher Colonel William Dalton Mann
Mann's business motives and power dynamics
Editorial style and content of Town Topics
The Saunterer column and information gathering
The blackmail scheme and spinoff publications
Sponsorship breaks and transition
Blind items and journalistic legacy
Scandalous stories involving Alice Roosevelt
The Edwin Post blackmail sting operation
The sting execution and Collier's campaign
The trial and Mann's perjury
Aftermath and legal consequences for Mann
Modern parallels and cautionary tales
Unanswered questions about Mann's secrets
Joe Pompeo's other works and research interests
Conclusion and guest contact information
Listen ad-free on Castria