The Blindboy Podcast The Blindboy Podcast

Frantic Canter, Bowsy Gallop

Jul 29, 2020 · 1h 20m

Summary

Blindboy presents a "hot take" arguing that early American pop music (1850–1920) was predominantly sung with an Irish accent, even by non-Irish performers. He traces this influence to the popularity of Thomas Moore’s sheet music and the dominance of Irish tenor John McCormack in the early recording era. The episode also critically examines the dark history of Irish participation in minstrel shows, where Irish immigrants adopted blackface to gain social acceptance and whiteness in America.

Topics discussed

Lowe's Black Friday Deals Welcome and new listener advice Twitch streams and live musical writing New camera and gigging updates Irish diaspora and historical traces Defining pop music and its origins Hot take: African-American tonality in pop Elvis and the influence of R&B White singers using African-American intonation African-American roots of 20th-century music The shift from Irish to African-American accents Copyright expiration and royalty opportunities Example: I'm a Yiddish Cowboy Melting pot themes in early American pop Irish accents in non-Irish singers Normalization of African-American singing styles Technical issues: squeaky chair and mic The birth of pop music and sheet music Selling music in the 1800s via sheet music The middle-class parlour and leisure Playing simple tunes at home Thomas Moore and Irish folk melodies Last Rose of Summer and American sales Irish poverty and New York middle class United Irishmen and the 1798 Rebellion The Minstrel Boy and its origins Thomas Moore's friends and the rebellion Oral musical culture in Ireland Dark history of Irish in America Minstrel shows and mockery of Black people Cartoons and stereotypes of the Irish Irish and African-Americans as non-white Nativist Americans and British settlers Stock characters and blackface origins How the Irish Became White Frederick Douglass and Daniel O'Connell Douglass's tour of Ireland Irish distancing from Black people Frederick Douglass on white minstrels Irish in the Civil War and minstrel scene Thomas Rice and the creation of Jim Crow Irish Penal Laws and Jim Crow laws Segregation and the Jim Crow laws WASPs and Irish seeking approval Irish and African dance amalgamation The jig and its roots Irish indentured servants vs slaves Juba dance and Irish fiddle music Master Juba and tap dancing Master Juba and African dance roots Five Pints and Gangs of New York Spike Lee and the film's whitewashing Citizens Bank Ad Sling TV Ad Patreon support and independence Full-time work and research Patreon model and monthly picks Helping the podcast: reviews and follows Twitch channel details John McCormack and Irish accents James Joyce and John McCormack McCormack's popularity and Thomas Moore The Minstrel Boy as a McCormack hit McCormack's 'Aspirational Bogger' accent 1906 charts and American standards Tin Pan Alley and copyright Music publishing and royalties Writing sheet music and early records Defining novelty music Comedy vs novelty in Tin Pan Alley Novelty songs about current events Katie Casey and baseball lyrics Take Me Out to the Ball Game Transition Harvey Hindemeyer and Jewish songwriters Irish and Jewish roles in Tin Pan Alley Irish diaspora appeal in songs Nora Bays and songs about Cork Singing like a Paddy in 1910 Irish-American and Jewish songwriting teams Eddie Cantor and the New York accent YouTube research and Irish inflections K-pop and BTS global dominance Western producers in Korea File sharing and music revenue loss BTS and the future of global power Prediction: Korean inflections in pop Citizens Bank Ad McDonald's Ad

More from The Blindboy Podcast

Convicted Criminal Russell Brand and 2nd Century Christian Demonology
Nov 18, 2026
An expert tells me about water, Rivers and data centres
Nov 11, 2026
Museum Tour. I got lost in the city of Newcastle and became overwhelmed by a 2500 year old corpse
Nov 4, 2026
English myth and folklore with Professor Ronald Hutton
Oct 28, 2026
What Bebo chain letters can tell us about Anglo Saxon Pagan tree worship and the role of snakes in the evolution of human anxiety
Oct 20, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria