The Big Picture The Big Picture

‘The Social Reckoning’ Is No ‘The Social Network,’ and the Top Five Most Unnecessary Legasequels. Plus: The Best Movies at NYFF!

Oct 9, 2026 · 1h 54m

Summary

Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbin discuss Aaron Sorkin's new film, The Social Reckoning, while analyzing the impact of Skydance's acquisition of Paramount on upcoming franchises like Transformers and G.I. Joe. The hosts also share their impressions from the New York Film Festival, highlighting standout premieres such as Luca Guadagnino's Artificial, Tom McCarthy's A Statement, and Eleanor Coppola's Marie Antoinette making-of documentary.

Topics discussed

Intro: The Social Reckoning and Sorkin's return Sponsor: LinkedIn Ads Watching the film together and Skydance news Transformers reboot and Michael Bay's absence G.I. Joe legacy and 80s nostalgia Bradley Cooper as Duke and casting rumors Star Trek re-release and popcorn buckets The Godfather: The Offer and video games Al Pacino's current status and cameo ideas Damien Chazelle's prison movie and excitement College reunion and hosting the pod alone Taylor Swift closing the Academy Awards Skydance branding and recording the theme NYFF audience demographics and young viewers Festival strategy: NYFF vs Telluride and Venice Moonlight launch and festival immunity Lower risk, higher reward for NYFF premieres Press screenings and talent availability Amazon drops film, Neon picks it up Lucas's pre-film remarks and commitment Andrew Garfield's performance in the new film Pedro Pascal's passive protagonist role No Other Land follow-up and Glaser's production Painful viewing and Israeli government outcry Personal experience vs newspaper reporting Target rich environment and PTA concert film Cameron Winter's height and Benny Safdie Concert energy and after-party dynamics Nature documentary style and singer-songwriter tradition Win Win, Still Water, and coin flip directors Paul Giamatti, Turturro, and New York theater actors Marie Antoinette making-of documentary Behind the scenes: hair, sets, and extras Proving right about Marie Antoinette Family dynamics and cinematographer interaction Godzilla Minus Zero: action vs character Monster fighting and family Halloween costumes Mothra as a girl and daughter's preference Joy of Joys: Jonathan Glaser's short film Festival wrap-up and critics' prizes Alex Gibney's Elon Musk documentary Filmmaking choices and reliance on other reporting Public service value and theatrical release Disorienting audio and missing testimony Musk's self-transformation and engineer identity Who needs to see it? Streaming availability Lack of ultimate philosophy or personal incident Unsympathetic portrait and grueling experience Ship in the night: Sorkin's half-written script Sequel issues: Sorkin directing and Fincher's absence Network TV procedural feel and acting quality Journalism movie vs courtroom film structure Low stakes and gentle pacing issues Sorkin's social media promotion paradox Lack of character exploration and opinion attachment Old school theatrical structures and female independence Breaking NDA and the promise of Facebook Pollyanna view of Facebook's common good Massive reveal and disclosure day parallels Boomerish quality and Mark Zuckerberg's absence All the President's Men structural borrowing TV writing callbacks and comedy failures Mikey Madison miscast and celiac neuropathy Lack of development and Instagram tip-off Excruciating opening sequence and Sorkin's tone Facebook mom movie and Thanksgiving uncle vibes Insufficient justification for the film's existence Bill Burr as Sorkin stand-in and fact-checking Filmmaking attempts: fog, camera moves, atmosphere Bill Burr vs Jeremy Strong and ethical debates Flashbacks, ornateness, and lack of pace Sequel should show choices, not acquisition of info HBO docudrama feel and Jay Roach comparisons Potential for improvement and recasting needs Sorkin-specific moments and towel throw Bruce Springsteen in Deliver Me From Nowhere Sean Durkin vs Sorkin and wanting better Mikey Madison's performance and female portrayal Fincher's potential impact on character portrayal Washington Post growth and NYT response Fist pump callback and Facebook's continued growth Tonal imbalance and Jeremy Allen White's role Sub 10 million box office and Meta's silence Skydance aggressive pursuit and Bond theme sing West Wing originality and Sorkin's influences Terminator 2 credit and desire for risk-taking Legacy sequels: Top Gun Maverick and The Strangers The First Omen and upcoming draft Jurassic World: Chris Pratt and brontosaurus The Matrix Resurrections and Project Popcorn Ghostbusters Afterlife and Mad Max Fury Road Sick period recovery and H2O reference Double feature benefit and Artificial vs Reckoning Ben Affleck's Animals and Hall of Fame Mother Mommy screening and tomorrow's interview
Listen ad-free on Castria