The Big Dig The Big Dig

The Staten Island Problem

Aug 12, 2026 · 36m

Summary

In this episode of Revisionist History, producer Ben Nadeff-Haffrey explores the 1990s Staten Island secession movement, the largest since the Civil War. The story centers on the clash between Mayor David Dinkins and Borough President Guy Molinari, fueled by racial tensions, police unrest, and the Fresh Kills landfill. This historical conflict involving figures like Rudy Giuliani and Donald Trump serves as a lens to examine modern political polarization and the fragility of democracy.

Topics discussed

Intro and Quince sponsorship Introduction to The Staten Island Problem series Staten Island as the forgotten borough New York City in the late 1980s David Dinkins' rise to mayor The threat of Staten Island secession Sponsors: Revision Energy and Davis Malm The Kiko Garcia shooting and riots Guy Molinari's feud with Dinkins Sponsor: M&M Skylights Dinkins' humiliating visit to Staten Island The Fresh Kills landfill controversy Conclusion and series promotion
Listen ad-free on Castria